| MCFL All League | NFE All Americans | AFA All Americans | |
| 1st Team | Ryan Rhodes, CB | ||
| Joe McGinnis, DE | |||
| James Duncan, SS | |||
| 2nd Team | Ryan Rhodes, RS | ||
| Mike Cook, P | |||
| 3rd Team | |||
| Honorable Mention | Tim Penning, OG | ||
| Dexter Stallworth, WR | |||
| Dan Smith, OT | |||
| Paul Carter, RB | |||
| Chad Jenkins, FB | |||
| Trent Rice, OLB | |||
| Keith Jackson, MLB | |||
| Lewis Gregg, CB | |||
| Mike Smith, AP | |||
| Special Recognition | Dexter Stallworth, WR | ||
| MCFL Offensive MVP | |||
| Joe McGinnis, DE | |||
| MCFL Defensive MVP | |||
| TEAM AWARDS | |||
| Most Valuable Player | |||
| Offensive Most Valuable Player | |||
| Defensive Most Valuable Player | |||
| Offensive Lineman of the Year | |||
| Deffensive Lineman of the Year | |||
| Offensive Back of the Year | |||
| Defensive Back of the Year | |||
| Special Teams Player of the Year | |||
| Most Improved Player | |||
| Rookie of the Year | |||
| Rudy Award | |||
| Team USA - Mustangs players who played in Braunschweig, Germany | |||
| Kevin Armour, ass't coach | |||
| Don Stradling, WR | |||